Our research project

Asylum procedures, which determine whether someone qualifies for international protection, are complex. UNPACK integrates insights from four disciplines to unpack that complexity.

Why are we doing this?

Asylum procedures are shaped by complex interactions between linguistic, socio-cultural, psychological and legal factors. Yet we know relatively little about how these different dimensions interact in everyday practice.

Moreover, EU law requires asylum procedures to be ‘fair’, but what fairness means in this context remains largely undefined and under-theorized.

UNPACK seeks to deepen our understanding of how these interactions shape the experiences of those involved and the way asylum procedures unfold in practice. It also aims to contribute to the development of an evidence-based framework for understanding and assessing fairness in asylum procedures.

Law

Whether applicants receive international protection depends on their personal stories and on whether they qualify as refugees or as persons eligible for subsidiary protection. The applicable rules are laid down at international, European and national level. But how do these rules work in practice? The legal component of UNPACK explores how they are understood, applied and navigated by the Legal Department, asylum officers, applicants and lawyers.

Linguistics

During the asylum interview, personal accounts often need to be interpreted, before being translated and recorded in the written case file. The language component of UNPACK investigates the linguistic complexity of the procedure from the perspectives of interpreters, asylum officers, and applicants for international protection, with the aim of improving our understanding of how communicative practices, multilingual repertoires, and language mediation shape the assessment of asylum applications.

Anthropology

Diversity and socio-cultural sensitivities permeate the asylum procedure. The key anthropological question is how these differences and othering practices shape the interactions and (power) dynamics among the actors. The anthropological component focuses on the Country-of-Origin Information research unit, CEDOCA: how does it find, process, interpret, and share relevant information? Researching the case handling processes through an anthropological lens consists in examining how diversity-related issues play out in the interactions and encounters that constitute the asylum procedure.

Psy/Social

The psychological component investigates how trauma, mental health, emotions, and well-being are intertwined with the experiences of both asylum applicants and professionals during the asylum procedure. It examines the mental well-being of asylum professionals and explores how organisational factors, such as workload and institutional support, influence their psychological functioning. We further explore how wellbeing possibly affects applicants’ narratives and interactions throughout the asylum process.

How does this research work?

The research takes off along two tracks, across the four disciplines.

1. The organization of the asylum procedure

We carry out fieldwork, through observations, interviews and document analysis, within the supporting services of the Belgian asylum authorities (CGRS): the Legal Department, the Interpreters’ Service, the country-of-origin information service (CEDOCA) and the Human Resources Department.

2. The case files in the asylum procedure

We follow individual case files through observations of asylum interviews, which are also audio-recorded. We speak with applicants, asylum officers, interpreters and lawyers, both within and beyond the walls of the CGRS.

3. Integration of insights

In a third step, we will analyse how the organizational context and individual case files interact, bringing together the different dimensions of fairness.

Finally, we will connect our findings to other research fields and explore how fairness can be strengthened in policy and practice.